Best Coffee Subscriptions 2021: Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

This post has affiliate links. At no cost to you, we earn a commision for puchases made through links in this post. Read more
1. The Original Donut 2. McCafe Premium 3. Green Mountain

Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods Best Coffee Subcriptions

McCafe Premium Roast Keurig K Cup Coffee Pods

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic


If you are a true coffee lover, you will agree when I say that there’s no better feeling than drinking a mug of delicious, steaming coffee in the comfort of your own home.

Imagine how lovely it would be- waking up to a package of your favorite kind of coffee, delivered right at your doorstep.


This is exactly what you can expect from monthly coffee subscriptions – packages filled with the goodness of caffeine.

At this time, when even the thought of getting out of your house for a cup of coffee is unfathomable, you can quench your thirst for caffeine with the help of the best coffee subscriptions.

These subscriptions can be monthly or weekly, depending on how frequently you drink coffee.

They are safely mailed to your doorstep, and thus, don’t require you to get out of your house, every time you crave your favorite beverage. They can also be customized according to your taste and love for caffeine.

Coffee subscriptions come in different forms. Some have more quantity but less quality. Some offer additional perks to their consumers, while others don’t even provide authentic beans.

It’s quite natural to get confused in this chaos, and end up getting a subscription that is certainly not the right one for you.

This concise guide will make these choices more organized and clear for you, so that you can get the best coffee subscription for your caffeine-deprived taste buds.

Factors To Consider Before Purchasing Best Coffee Subscription

As the popularity of monthly coffee subscriptions is growing, your choices of the same are also growing rapidly.

Major coffee houses are coming up with their monthly plans, and new varieties are being introduced. Some packages are even customized according to your caffeine craving. So, how do you know which one to choose?

We are here to guide you through this confusing mayhem, and eventually help you find your best caffeine supply partner. Here are some of the most important factors to consider before buying a coffee subscription.

1. Quality Coffee

Almost all the subscriptions give a good amount of coffee that will generally last for a month. However, what’s the point of purchasing it if you don’t get that authentic touch of caffeine? This is why you should definitely take notice of the quality mentioned on the coffee package.

Try purchasing premium Arabica beans or specialty grade coffee to improve your coffee experience.

If you are a light coffee drinker, stay away from a medium roast or dark roast. Maxwell coffee might be the best coffee subscription for you.

You can also go for those roasters, who roast their beans in batches. This method is great to trap all the intense flavor and aroma of the coffee beans.

Some coffee houses have an automatic renewal system where the cancellation is only allowed after three months or even six months. Always try a sample before purchasing such coffee. There are many coffee houses that provide a sample before finalizing the subscription.

2. Flexibility In Quantity

The quantity of the coffee you order depends on the amount of caffeine you consume on a regular basis.

Mostly, companies will encourage you to go for their “set and forget” feature but this can actually end up being problematic for you.

These companies pack an ample amount of coffee for an average drinker. However, you could either be someone who just needs one cup of morning coffee, or a workaholic who drinks coffee every hour.

In such cases, the quantity of coffee can either be too less or too much. This is why you should go for subscriptions that are flexible with their quantity. There are mostly two methods of maintaining flexibility in your orders.

One option allows you to adjust the frequency of your deliveries. You can modify your settings to receive packages two times in a month or even once a week.

This option is the best coffee subscription choice for true coffee connoisseurs.
This option is also preferred by people who don’t drink coffee much.

For example, you can just order the quantity of coffee that is suitable for a week, and not order anything until you have consumed your current stash of coffee.

An additional way of receiving flexibility in the quantity of your ordered coffee is for a subscription service to allow a gradual change in the amount of coffee you opt to receive.

For example, instead of urging an option only between 250g or 1kg per month, the monthly subscription company should permit you to select between numerous different amounts.

3. Per Kilo Pricing

Some of the major coffee house subscriptions have this problem where the increment of the price is not consistent with the per kg increase.

It is actually very hard to find a coffee subscription that will permit you to customize your coffee amount, without it being a burden on your budget.

For example, suppose you are an avid coffee drinker, your. monthly deliveries amount to about 1 kg of coffee. However, you realize that you need more coffee beans or ground powder.

While you were being charged $50 for 1 kg, you realise that on customising the quantity of your monthly coffee, the price increases excessively when you add just 250g more.

Sometimes, the per kg pricing of some companies is too bizaare. This is why you should try to invest in a coffee house that has a fixed amount attached to their quantity.

4. Fresh Deliveries

This is something most companies offer because it’s a given that coffee tastes the best when it’s fresh. Most subscription services do an outstanding job of delivering freshly roasted coffee to their customers. They often claim to use different ways to ensure that the coffee you receive is a new batch of roasted beans. However, there are few ways to know for certain if they really mean what they claim.

  • Packaging – the company will spend a little more on their packaging if they care about the freshness of their beans. They will seal the packets so that no flavor or aroma can escape from the packed bag.
  • Grading – The companies that are specialty graded usually offer a good fresh batch of coffee. It is safer to go for these companies since they have already attained a level of success which is why they can invest in big roasters.
  • Roasting – The method of roasting plays a big part in trapping the freshness of coffee beans. They must be roasted in small batches to get the best result.

5. Perks

This is where many companies fail to impress. Now, who wouldn’t love a coffee house that provides additional benefits at the same price as its counterparts? You can get many such benefits depending on the company you invest in.

For example, the Bean Box provides four gourmet flavors of coffee. This definitely makes it one of the best coffee subscriptions for everyone.

One package of Bean Box subscription contains four variations which range from sweet, creamy, and thick coffee to dark, bitter, and black coffee. This kind of company understands that you may need a different variation of coffee depending on your mood, and they offer you exactly that.

There are other coffee houses that supply cookies with your monthly subscription. You can even choose different variations of coffees in a single package.

For example, you can go for decaf coffee and a hazelnut flavor. It completely depends on your taste buds. This kind of monthly subscription is rapidly gaining more and more attention which is why a majority of coffee houses are implementing and designing new packages for their customers.

This guide will help you know about these brands and their packages. You can select the best one for you, depending on factors like taste, flavor, budget, and quantity.

Top 12 Best Coffee Subscriptions 2021

1. The Original Donut Shop 

p Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods Best Coffee Subcriptions.This medium roasted coffee is filled with rich and delicious flavor. As the name suggests, you would expect this coffee to taste sugary and almost too sweet. However, that’s not the case with these K-Cups. They contain an extra bold flavor with the smoothest texture and aroma to quench your thirst for caffeine.

The Original Donut Coffee is made of pure Arabica beans which gives it a strong taste without leaving any burnt or bitter aftertaste. These K-Cup Pods claim to contain more coffee than you can find in conventional pods. The price of their monthly subscriptions isn’t very high, and you get about 72 K-cup Pods in a single purchase.


  • It contains pure Arabica coffee beans.
  • The coffee is bold and flavorful, which is great for strong coffee drinkers.
  • It doesn’t leave any burnt or bitter aftertaste.
  • It has more coffee in every single pod than other K-cup brands.


  • It can only work with Keurig Brewers.
  • Mild coffee drinkers won’t like the strong flavor.

2. McCafe Premium Roast

McCafe Premium Roast Keurig K Cup Coffee PodsThis McCafe Premium Coffee contains a powerful and unique blend of rich Arabica coffee and other different mountain coffee beans. These beans are carefully handpicked and roasted with precision to give you a rich and flavorful cup of caffeine.

The coffee beans are grown and harvested in popular coffee-growing estates present in the mountains. They carefully select the beans harvested in a single estate farm so that they can pick the ones with the most uniform shape and size. After the procedure of collecting, they are expertly roasted in such a way that they do not lose their flavor and aroma. It is also very affordable and the subscription of this package will give you 84 pods of coffee every month.


  • It is affordable and gives more pods of coffee than its counterparts.
  • It is medium roasted to the point where it’s not too strong or too mild.
  • The flavor is well balanced.
  • It is a blend of pure rich coffee beans.
  • It is compatible with all Keurig K-Cup brewers, including the Keurig 2.0 brewer, too.


  • The flavor of this coffee is mild to slightly strong. It may not be preferred by strong coffee drinkers.
  • It comes in only one variety, with no option of decaf or a stronger flavor.
  • After analyzing the reviews of this product, many customers complained about the pods not being compatible with

3. Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark MagicIf you are looking for the best coffee subscription below 30 dollars, you may have found the one for you. This coffee will bewitch you with its dark magic of perfectly roasted pure Arabica beans. This coffee contains single-origin pure mountain beans that will give you a cup filled with rich texture and flavor.

The coffee beans are grown on mountains without using any artificial means like pesticides or other chemical substances. It is seen that the water provided is fresh and clean. The brand also ensures that the trees grown for these coffee farms are completely new and fresh. The methods that are used in picking and harvesting these coffee beans are incredibly eco-friendly, making it great for your overall health. You will get about 72 K-Cups with one purchase.


  • Single-origin coffee beans
  • They contain 100% pure Arabica beans.
  • No pesticides or chemicals are used in the manufacturing process.
  • The flavor of this coffee is bold, deep, and intense. Thus, it is great for strong coffee drinkers.
  • The aftertaste has nutty and chocolate undertones.


  • It is manufactured for old-style brewers. Therefore, it won’t be compatible with brewers like Keurig 2.0.
  • Some reviews stated that the coffee beans would almost always clog up their brewers.
  • The taste is too strong for mild coffee drinkers.

4. Dunkin’ Original Blend Medium Roast Coffee

Dunkin' Original Blend Medium Roast CoffeeThis popular brand has its signature taste and you must be already aware of it. The Dunkin’ Coffee is blended and manufactured in such a way that you can get that signature Dunkin’ Donut taste at your home in your cup of coffee. All you have to do is mix 1.5 tablespoons of ground coffee in 6 fl oz of water to get that creamy, thick, and sweet taste.

This premium coffee can be a great base for making other varieties of coffee like cappuccino, affogato, or a cup of sweet iced coffee. Pure Arabica beans are used to make this wonderful blend of coffee. You will get 60 K-Cup Coffee Pods for every single purchase. If you are someone who likes their coffee light and sweet, then this might be one of the best coffee subscriptions for you.


  • Great for light coffee drinkers.
  • It has a signature Dunkin’ Donut taste.
  • It can work as a great base for cooking or baking.
  • Other varieties of coffee like an affogato will taste great with it.
  • The texture of this coffee is thick, creamy, and smooth.


  • Too sweet for even mild coffee drinkers.
  • It has no signature boost of caffeine.

5. Caribou Coffee Caribou Blend

Caribou Coffee Caribou BlendThe brand, Caribou Coffee, is the first primary U.S. coffeehouse to supply only 100% Rainforest Alliance Certified coffee as well as espresso. This signifies that they always take care of their farmers, providing them with adequate wages and making the community feel more stable and secured. The coffee beans that are supplied from this brand are eco-friendly and chemical-free.

Rich and famous Indonesian coffee beans are used to manufacture this product. It comes in four different variations, each of them roasted perfectly to provide unique aromatic flavors. This coffee is medium roasted to produce a balanced sweet, spicy, and subtle note of berries. They contain the aftertaste of bittersweet cocoa, and a smooth creamy texture.


  • It has a balanced acidity.
  • The flavor contains the spicy, woodsy taste of Indonesian coffee.
  • The aftertaste is the bittersweet taste of cocoa.
  • Rainforest Alliance Certified
  • Single Estate Coffee.
  • It is medium roasted to give a balanced taste.


  • The flavor can taste weak to some people.
  • Only compatible with Keurig coffee makers.

6. Peet’s Coffee Major Dickason’s Blend

Peet's Coffee Major Dickason's BlendPeet’s Coffee Blend is rich, smooth, and sophisticated, with an incredibly full-bodied and multi-layered profile. This brand incorporates the best coffee beans from the world’s exclusive coffee growing areas, each imparting its unique local traits while still seamlessly rounding into a smooth, stabilized cup of steaming coffee. This blend comes pre-grounded for short and simple brewing.

These beans are carefully selected and only the best coffee beans go into the processing of this product. Roasting is done in batches so that each batch of coffee attains a perfect roast without losing its distinct flavor and aroma. The team of Major Dickason’s makes sure that only 100% fresh and pure coffee beans reach you.


  • A unique coffee blend made by combining the coffee beans from all the premier coffee growing regions.
  • Carefully dark roasted in small batches.
  • 100% pure and fresh coffee beans.
  • It comes in vacuum-sealed packages.
  • This is great for dark coffee drinkers.


  • The acidity level is higher than the other coffees.
  • Not great for light or mild coffee drinkers.

7. Bean Box Sampler – Freshly Roasted Coffee Subscription

Bean Box Sampler - Freshly Roasted Coffee SubscriptionThis unique subscription contains four gourmet coffees for every month. This brand was officially rated as the best subscription coffee 2019 in Portland and Seattle. These four gourmet flavors consist of Crema Blend, Peru Flor de Selva, Queen City Blend, and Stacya’s Blend. All of these flavors are freshly roasted before they are sent to you, so that you don’t get any bitter or burnt aftertaste.

This box of caffeine contains a little something for every coffee drinker. Crema Blend has a chocolate finish to it which produces a thick, creamy, and smooth texture. Peru Flor de Selva has a sweet pink apple taste intertwined with dried cranberries and a little bitter cocoa. Queen city blend is a dark roasted coffee with a melted butter aroma. It has no fruity flavors.

Stacya’s Blend is basically a mix of the other three blends. You will get a taste of chocolate, sugary citrus, and just a whiff of crisp marshmallow in this flavorful coffee. This coffee is great for light coffee drinkers.


  • This is an award-winning brand.
  • You get four rich delicious coffee in one package.
  • The beans are always freshly brewed.
  • Roasting is done in small batches.
  • None of the coffees contains artificially added flavors.


  • It is very expensive.
  • The quantity offered per bag is very less according to the price.

8. Maxwell House Master Blend Light Roast Ground Coffee

Maxwell House Master Blend Light Roast Ground CoffeeIf you have an automatic drip brewer, then this may be the best coffee subscription for you. The coffee beans are skillfully selected and roasted to perfection so that you can get the full flavor of Arabica. They use 100% real and authentic coffee beans to make this product.

Maxwell House Master Blend Coffee roasts small batches of coffee to a light roast which gives you a beverage with no immediate jitters but enough caffeine to feel energized. The consistency of this coffee is very smooth and gentle. The taste has no bitterness in it. The coffee beans will provide a very mellow and soft touch to your palette.


  • It can be used as a base in cooking and baking.
  • The formula contains 100% real authentic coffee.
  • The texture is very smooth and velvety.
  • Great for light coffee drinkers.
  • It works perfectly in an automatic drip brewer.
  • It is very affordable.


  • Not suitable for mild or strong coffee drinkers.
  • It can taste too sweet.
  • It has almost no caffeine kick to it.

9. Match Made Coffee – Craft Coffee & Gourmet Cookie Subscription Box

Match Made Coffee - Craft Coffee & Gourmet Cookie Subscription BoxThis unique and delicious subscription pack contains 4 oz of international and delicious coffee. Each box of your subscription contains 2 gourmet cookies that are intricately spiced up to pair flawlessly with the given coffee roast. The company’s award-winning cookie bakery develops flavorful recipes varying from Red Velvet to Taro to Lemon Bar, and many more.

Imagine the pleasure you will feel each month, when you see a package of delicious roasted coffee waiting for you on your doorstep, along with the most flavorful cookie curated especially for your beverage. The cookies that you get from this subscription include Salted caramel cream cookie, Red velvet cookie, PB Overload Cookie, and Taro cookie.

Each month you will receive 4 oz of coffee, 2 packets of cookies with each packet weighing at 2 oz, and pairing notes. The type of coffee you get depends on your cookie. The Japanese Taro cookie is paired with Papua New Guinea Kiam Coffee because of its sweetness. If you love mild to dark roasted coffee, PB Overload cookie with Global Collective Blend might be the best for you.

Strong Espresso coffee is paired with a rich and sweet flavor of Red velvet cookie. The spicy Honduras San Marcos Coffee is paired with the Salted Caramel Cream cookie.


  • The uniqueness of flavors and pairings of cookies creates a whirlwind of tanginess in your mouth.
  • Premium quality coffee beans are used.
  • You can select a pairing depending on what kind of coffee you prefer.
  • The monthly shipping cost is free.
  • It comes with a 1-year warranty.
  • It contains no added flavors or preservatives.
  • A fun experience.


  • It is expensive.
  • The quantity offered is less than the price given.
  • They provide only ground coffee.

10. Un’kuppd Pour-over Coffee – Barista Approved Pour-Over Coffee Subscription

It consists of fifteen, single-serve Un’kup bags of specialty-grade, pour-over coffee. Un’kuppd provides a diverse, monthly collection of specialty grade coffees from the US and European coffee roasters. The process to make this cup of coffee is also extremely easy and convenient. All you need is some hot water and your cup of steaming hot coffee is ready.

This is ground coffee where you just tear the top and pour the content into a mug of hot water. You do not need to buy any brewer machine for this product. This is one of the best coffee subscriptions for you if you don’t like the taste of instant coffee; but at the same time, you cannot afford a brewer machine.


  • No equipment is needed.
  • The coffee is nitro sealed so that the fresh flavor and aroma get trapped.
  • It is not instant coffee. The coffee crystals are pure authentic grounded coffee beans.It is convenient and portable.Specialty grade
  • coffee, which means that they have earned over 80 points on a 100 points scale.
  • No artificial ingredients or sweeteners are used.Great for black coffee lovers.


  • No sweetener is provided to you. Hence, you will need more ingredients if you are not a fan of black coffee.
  • It claims to be an assortment of different variations of coffee. But it has only two variations in a 12 pack of coffee bags

11. My Coffee And Book Club

My Coffee And Book ClubMy Coffee And Book Club is the best coffee subscription for every bookworm. Every month, they will deliver 12 ounces of ground coffee or whole beans, along with two hardcover novels. You have the option of changing your genre or the type of coffee any time you want.

My Coffee and Book Club delivers premium quality gourmet coffee at your doorstep. Their coffee is made of 100% pure Arabica beans. You get the option to select ground coffee or whole beans, depending on whether you have a brewing machine or not. You get a free ebook of your selected books, in case you are traveling and you need something to read.

They give you the option to choose from genres like Fiction, Non-Fiction, Mystery, Horror, and Science Fiction. Their curator will work with your genre and he will select two books that might be the best for you. Every month, you will be surprised to see what books are selected for you.


  • A new innovative idea.
  • You can choose ground coffee or whole beans.
  • It contains pure 100% Arabica coffee.
  • You can choose books or genres.
  • If you are confused, you can also go for “surprise me.”


  • The quantity of coffee is less for the price.

12. AmazonFresh Colombia Ground Coffee

AmazonFresh Colombia Ground CoffeeThey firmly believe that “Fresh is the best”, which is why you can count on AmazonFresh to deliver freshly roasted coffee at your doorstep. Their coffee beans are roasted in small individual batches before being directly sent to you.

You also get the choice of choosing your own roast. Based on your taste, you get to decide if you need a light roast, medium roast, or dark roast. They are all full-bodied and well-balanced in terms of acidity, and customized according to your taste.

One package of AmazonFresh consists of three bags of coffee, each weighing at about 12 ounces. They are made of 100% Columbian Arabica coffee. These beans are carefully selected, sun-dried, and perfectly roasted before they are sent to you.

There are other variations of AmazonFresh which are in the form of whole beans, or K-Cup pods. You also get an easy refund option and return option. The cancellation of your subscription can also be done anytime.


  • The packaging is great.
  • They deliver fresh and pure Columbian Arabica.
  • You can select the roast level.
  • AmazonFresh is very affordable.
  • Easy refund and return policy.
  • Easy cancellation process.
  • The beans are full-bodied with a smooth finish.
  • It has a subtle citrusy aroma with a hint of cocoa as an aftertaste.


  • Not a premium coffee.
  • It has a hint of a bitter taste.
  • Even the light roast tastes strong and bold.
  • According to some reviewers, instead of sweet citrusy aroma, it has a sour aroma.

FAQs on Coffee Subscriptions

Q1. Are Any Subscription Boxes Worth It?

There are many benefits to subscription boxes. You get easy deliveries every month and it’s like waiting for a surprise package to arrive. Some of them even have a “surprise me” feature where you just answer a few questions and they curate your package for you. This is an interesting experience for many people. Other benefits that come with subscription boxes are:

Custom Picked Items – With each subscription packet, the articles you obtain every month are selected particularly for you, based on your personal needs and intentions. This can be an outstanding boon for those who constantly get confused and face trouble in finding what they want in shops, or who just don’t like shopping much.

Convenience – Your time and effort is saved as you get these items delivered to you at your doorstep. It’s convenient and easy.

Possible Savings – When you buy any item in bulk, the amount of money you spend on them is less than the amount spent on buying them separately.

Q2. What Type Of Coffee Is The Least Bitter?

There are ways to make your coffee taste less bitter. However, there are also some varieties of coffee that are inherently less bitter than the others. For example, Arabica coffee beans are less bitter than Robusta beans. They are still bitter, but much less than Robusta.

Robusta coffee beans produce a strong and bold taste with bitterness left as an aftertaste. Their intensity is much stronger, and often undrinkable by most people. You can try adding sugar or cream but the bitterness of Robusta is almost impossible to neutralize.

Lightly roasted Arabica coffee beans barely have any bitterness to them. The only condition is that you must have pure Arabica beans, as they have a slightly woodsy taste and no burnt or strong flavor. It is the best coffee for you if you don’t like the strong flavor of coffee.

Many coffee subscriptions offer lightly roasted Arabica coffee. If you are confused between light roast and medium roast, then there are other options. The best coffee subscriptions are the ones that provide you with the opportunity of customizing your package. You can definitely select the roast you love after trying different flavors.

Q3. How Do Coffee Subscriptions Work?

Coffee subscriptions can be monthly or weekly purchases. Your preferred coffee house delivers a package filled with your favorite coffee at your doorstep.

While finalizing your subscription, you curate the best package of coffee for you. It can depend on the brand you prefer. Some of the best coffee subscriptions allow you to choose the roast level, while others give perks like cookies or books.

You select the best ones for you and then they form your selected package. You can also choose the frequency of your package. It’s easy and convenient. You don’t have to go out of your house and there is no wastage of coffee either.

Q4. Is It Necessary To Have A Brewing Machine For A Monthly Coffee Subscription?

No! You don’t have to buy any bulky machinery just for the sake of coffee subscriptions. There are a variety of options available that you can enjoy without making a dent in your pocket.

Coffee subscriptions come in different forms. They can include ground coffee or coffee beans, depending on your choice. Hence, you can choose ground coffee which does not require any brewing machine.
Wrapping Up

In a nutshell, coffee subscription boxes are easy, convenient, and fun to use. At this time, when the thought of going outside of your home seems scary, these subscriptions come to your rescue and provide you with what you love. I hope this guide will help you to successfully choose the best coffee subscription for you.

Happy caffeinating!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *